Aggie’s Bakery creates Milwaukee’s best cut-out cakes! Aggie’s delicious cake and original buttercream recipe have been wowing customers since 1977 and our reputation for quality designs and flavors are unsurpassed! Using our website to order a cut-out cake you can select a design, customize the cake, choose the pick-up or delivery date and time, and submit your order. You can customize these options: size, flavor, filling, frosting, message, colors and leave a note for the decorator. Aggie’s cut-out cakes can be be ready in as little as 48 hours, and the first available time / date to pick-up the cake or have it delivered is in the blue box on each product page. Otherwise, if you need something faster you can always order one of our QUICK CAKES to be completed in just 6 hours! Begin looking for your perfect cut-out cake by scrolling below or you can search for keywords in the top right corner of our website. Happy cut-out cake shopping and feel free to call us with any questions, but ordering online is fast and easy – Thank you!
No products were found matching your selection.
Not finding what you are looking for? Many of the cakes and baked goods we offer are not shown on our website, but you can Contact Us to submit a custom quote. Thank you for considering us, we would love to make you something delicious!
In your message please answer the following questions (please feel free to copy this list into the message and write your answers next to each question) so we can quickly send you firm options:
- What is your name and phone number?
- What is the date and time you would need to pick-up the cake?
- What cake flavor(s) would you like? (Note if there are multiple tiers please include the flavors for each tier)
- Options found here: https://www.aggiesbakery.com/flavors-fillings/
- What filling(s) would you like? (Note if there are multiple tiers please include the fillings for each tier)
- What frosting would you like?
- How many people do you need to serve?
- In a separate email sent to email@example.com please attach an example picture(s) of the cake design(s) you would like quoted
- If the cake would end up being smaller than what you have pictured based on your servings is that okay OR do you want the quote to be as close as possible to the picture regardless of your required serving sizes?
- Note any changes you would like made to the design of the cake using the attached picture as a the reference.
- If the cake has fondant (smooth covering or 3D pieces on the cake), let us know if you want the fondant on your cake or prefer buttercream.