Milwaukee’s Best Wedding Cakes!

Wedding Cake Tasting and Consultation Hours:

Monday – Tuesday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

Wednesday: NONE

Thursday – Friday: 10:00 am – 6:00 pm

Saturday: 9:00 am – 5:00 pm

     Sunday: 10:00 am – 2:00 pm

*Please Note: Our wedding menu includes: tiered cakes, cheesecakes, sheet cakes, cupcakes, assorted mini pastries, 4″ and 2″ pies, and cookies. Also, complimentary consultations are for wedding cakes only with an expected order of $300 or more.

The initial tasting and consultation is a personal 30 minute appointment with Aggie’s Wedding Cake and Dessert Coordinator to discuss your design, flavors and a price quote for your wedding cake and/or desserts. This personal consultation is FREE OF CHARGE for (2) guests. Each additional person beyond (2) is $5 each with a maximum of (4) guests total allowed per consultation. The $5 charge for person 3 or 4 is payable when arriving at our bakery. During your personal consultation you will be trying our 6 most popular cake and filling combinations:

  • cheesecake whip whip topping
  • marble cake with French cream filling
  • chocolate cake with raspberry filling
  • yellow cake with strawberry French cream filling
  • white cake with strawberry filling
  • red velvet cake with cream cheese filling.
  • You will also be sampling our 2 most popular frosting options: Aggie’s original buttercream and Aggie’s original chocolate buttercream.

If you opt for the complimentary consultation and afterwards decide you would like to try any alternative flavor and filling combinations, you may schedule the paid consultation for $25 with a 5-day notice where you will choose (3) customized cake flavor and filling combinations OR (5) mini pastry options if you opting for a sweet table / dessert bar instead. Otherwise you can always skip the complimentary consultation and book the paid consultation right away if you know you are looking for something specific. Please use our complete menu of flavor and fillings here: to create your (3) combinations and write them in the appointment note section when scheduling the paid consultation. Otherwise, please use our complete pastry menu here: to select the (5) you would like to sample. Thank you!

We look forward to meeting you and helping you create a beautiful and delicious wedding cake. Please use the online scheduling tool below or to the right to book your consultation today!